email:
password:

Register
Forum Stats
Total Threads:
4104

Total Posts:
10050

Top Posters
Michael 2304
Dylan 1805
onemiamibum 710
JennyJM 645
nicole 484
Francisco 301
m1nr 262
Marty 256
dav 199
kyle 176
Fla 155
ultron 146
henryjoebob 142
Xandy 133
manic 127
Jess 124
Sarah 123
Cindy 123
Adam 106
Jessica 104
Random Faqqing
What does Beta mean and how long will idiotechnica.com be in it?
Beta is a fancy schmancy technical term that means: We do not want to take any responsibility for the quality of our software at this time. Idiotechnica will always be in beta.
firefox_logo
idiotechnica.com uses CSS3 and is optimized for viewing in Firefox versions 3+
The Karate Kid

Review By: Michael
Posted On: 02/23/11 08:24 PM
Rating: 4

Directorr:
Harald Zwart

Cast:
Jaden Smith, Jackie Chan, Zhenwei Wang

Stars:

I was pleasantly surprised at how much I enjoyed this movie. I was skeptical, as I am of all remakes, that it could not compare to the original nor bring anything new to the table. It delivered on every aspect.

The story which wasn't all that original for a kung fu movie plot in the first place, was taken from the original. Sometimes the scenes feel inspired by, sometimes they are verbatim. As a huge fan of The Karate Kid, I was extremely pleased at how respectful Zwart's vision is to so many aspects of the original.

Jackie Chan plays Mr. Han and did a better job than you might think possible of conjuring Pat Morita's karate teaching Mr. Miyagi. Without seeming as old, Chan manages to pull off the combination of conflicted kung fu master with a troubled past. While you never get that he needs Jaden Smith as a friend the way Morita needed Ralph Macchio, the relationship is believable. The problem more than likely exists because Dre is much younger than Daniel was.

Jaden Smith ends up being another surprise, but after seeing him in the movie you realize that while he was born into blockbuster blood, his talent is fresh and unknown. You can't help but enjoy how much of his father he brings to his role without making it a hidden plot point. I find myself wondering if its implicit or not. Overall he does an excellent job of splitting the difference between being an aloof coward and a determined hero...something you'd think you couldn't get without Macchio.

A real bonus to the film is Dre's antagonist - Cheng played by Zhenwei Wang. He was the perfect chinese version of Zabka. As the brutal champ that needs to be brought down and taught some compassion at the same time...he nailed it and brought some pretty impressive fight scenes with him. He both looks and acts like John Cheung who played Bruce Lees arch enemy in 'Dragon - The Bruce Lee Story'. I expect he has a future as a martial arts action star.

One odd aspect of the movie is that they seem to disrespect the art of karate itself in favor of kung fu. I have knowledge of neither nor do I care about any rivalry between the two arts, but it seems funny to me that they would go out of their way to poo poo karate and then name the movie 'The Karate Kid'. It could have easily been named the kung fu kid (which it was called internationally) and left the karate disrespect out without the irony of the name. I guess it was a marketing decision.

This movie gets a big 2 thumbs up from me failing only in a few places where the story feels forced. Ultimately, I am left feeling disappointed that I didn't catch this in the theater. It's definitely worth renting...its also currently available on Netflix. So check it out.
Leave Comment:
Comment
Submit Post

Posts: Movies and Television / The Karate Kid

share this thread on facebook

Posted By: Xandy
02/26/11 09:32 PM

Also currently OnDemand on Starz!
Posted By: kyle
02/27/11 03:49 AM

I really liked the part where the kid threw a jacket on the ground and picked it up for a few hours for a few days and then after one twelve second practice, became a championship caliber Kung Fu kid.
Posted By: Michael
02/28/11 06:08 PM

yeah. that was a little silly. they could have waited a few more lessons before he was that good.
Posted By: Virginia
03/01/11 11:49 PM

I enjoyed your review. While I agree with the most part of your assessment I did however feel that Chan was not as endearing as Miyaki nor was the relationship between the two as tight. Chan did a great job but perhaps he does not have the round face, deep set wrinkles, and passion for horticultural that created the Miyaki allure for me in the first place. This is odd b/c I have always considered Chan to be a very likable guy so I went it with the assumption that he would live up to that role for me but he just did not do it for me. On the other hand, I found the bully situation in this version to be more believable then in the original, I think this is cultural for me. For some reason I believe that a bunch of kids from a collectivist culture would really dislike a charismatic outsider versus a bunch of surfer boys from Cali. Finally, I loved the setting of the movie and felt that it was a character in it's own right. Specifically enjoyed seeing Asian suburbia, as well as, some of the more historical sites.
Posted By: Michael
03/02/11 01:10 PM

i agree that he wasnt as good, but he was still very good.