email:
password:

Register for Free! RSS Feed
Random Faqqing
There seem to be lots of things missing or that just plain don't work.
That's not a question. Its a statement. It's an honest mistake to be sure, but maybe its a sign that you should start spending more time thinking about how you might improve yourself and a little less time nitpicking every little detail of any given website.
firefox_logo
idiotechnica.com uses CSS3 and is optimized for viewing in Firefox versions 3+
French to ban a Muslim religious tradition?

http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/islam/beliefs/images/niqab.jpg CBC.ca reports on a French parliamentary panel that released a report recommending all women show their faces in public places including hospitals, schools, and public transit.

Personally I'm a bit torn on the issue, if the recommendation was to combat some existing problem wherein crimes were being committed by veiled suspects then I would tend to agree. It isn't like society hasn't let go of religious based traditions in favour of public security and health (hi, bloodletting!) however upon reading the article, the motivation behind the veil-ban seems less cut and dry.

From the article: "French President Nicolas Sarkozy has made face-veils a political issue, saying last summer that burkas imprison women and that they would not be tolerated in France."


"The recommendations come after a committee of 32 legislators from four political parties convened six months ago to address the wearing of burkas or niqabs, which are often viewed in France as a gateway to extremism and an insult to gender equality."

Though personally I would always champion gender equality over religious tradition, Muslim representative Mohammed Moussaoui raises a good point: "It's very difficult to talk about the liberation of women through a law that constrains."

What do you think? Should issues of gender equality be raised in a legal context or should we rely on cultural inertia to phase out old traditions?
Leave Comment:
Comment
Submit Post

Posts: Links / French to ban a Muslim religious tradition?

share this thread on facebook

Posted By: Virginia
01/26/10 11:20 AM

the is definitely a very complex issue. I am very surprised that French government is considering it. I remember hearing on NPR some years back about the high level of animosity felt by the french toward the Muslim population there. The french, similarly to the many americans, have blamed the Muslims for the bad economy and lack of jobs. Although I have no clue if cultural integration was at a influence in their decision making.

Whatever the reason, however, I do not think there is enough evidence showing that women who cover there face in these situations cause any ill effects. While I think no doubt that some cultural practices, specifically those that are blatantly sexiest toward women, need to be stopped and I am sure will be eventually once more women globally become educated. I am not sure if doing it this way is the best means. Furthermore the fact that they want to extend it to not only to public buildings but also on the streets violates a person's free rights and wasn't that the very reason we were fighting in Iraq in the first place, at least according to Bush.


Posted By: Shunoo
01/29/10 03:48 PM

Based on experience, my skin tone is not welcome at ALL in Europe. I went to London a couple years ago and I had possibly the worst service wherever I went. Empty taxi's passing us by, tables all the way in the back, some poor language and etc. Going out and getting heckled by a black guy? Come on.

Anyways, I haven't seen a Ninja (that's what muslim guys call girls that wear the scarves) commit any crimes, so why have them show their face? It's not like she's Reptile from Mortal Kombat and going to spew out a substance and melt your face off.
Posted By: Michael
01/29/10 04:41 PM

what if she IS reptile? in which case...awesome.